Jonathan and David

 There is a tenderness in Scripture that our modern world rarely knows what to do with.

When David and Jonathan’s friendship unfolds across the pages of 1 Samuel, it carries a kind of emotional and physical closeness that unsettles contemporary readers. We live in a world that flattens human intimacy into one of two categories: sexual or sterile. But the friendship of Jonathan and David offers us something altogether different — something holy, embodied, and deeply faithful.

“The soul of Jonathan was knit to the soul of David, and Jonathan loved him as his own soul.”

— 1 Samuel 18:1

From their first meeting, this is not the shallow camaraderie of shared interest; it is a covenantal knitting together. Jonathan’s affection is expressed through costly surrender — he strips himself of his robe, armor, sword, and bow and places them in David’s hands. In doing so, he is not only honoring David’s anointing but relinquishing his own claim to power. This act is not erotic; it is profoundly covenantal. It is the language of loyalty that has skin on it.

Their friendship is embodied in ways we rarely see among men today — and rarely allow ourselves to imagine among friends in general. They weep together. They hold one another. They bless one another with physical touch and tears. When Jonathan dies, David’s lament breaks open with a line that still confounds modern readers:

“Your love to me was wonderful, surpassing the love of women.”

— 2 Samuel 1:26

1. A Covenant of Souls, Not of Flesh

This was no secret romance disguised as friendship. It was something that cuts deeper: a covenantal devotion between two men who bore witness to God’s promises in each other’s lives. The Hebrew word ahavah (“love”) that describes their bond is the same used for God’s steadfast love for His people.

The love between Jonathan and David points to the reality that all true friendship participates in the covenant faithfulness of God. It’s not erotic desire that animates their closeness but mutual surrender — a willingness to give, protect, and bless, even when it costs something.

2. The Body as Witness to Affection

What makes many modern readers uncomfortable is how embodied their friendship is. They embrace. They kiss. They cry. We are so conditioned to interpret touch through sexual categories that we struggle to see physical affection as a language of loyalty, tenderness, or spiritual kinship.

But Scripture never divorces the soul from the body. Humans are not disembodied spirits; we are incarnate beings who express love, grief, and covenant through touch, presence, and gesture. The body bears witness to what the heart feels.

To be human is to need touch — not always in sexual ways, but as reassurance, solidarity, and blessing. Jonathan and David remind us that the body can express covenant love without corrupting it.

3. A Friendship That Prefigures Christ

Jonathan’s love for David is, in many ways, Christlike. He lays down privilege and inheritance for the sake of another’s calling. He chooses faithfulness over fear, love over power. Their friendship foreshadows the truest Friend — the One who said, “Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends.” (John 15:13)

In this way, Jonathan and David’s friendship is not merely emotional intimacy; it’s theological. It reveals the kind of self-giving affection that Christ Himself would later embody — love that pours itself out for the sake of another’s flourishing.

4. Recovering Holy Affection

In our world, affection is often either hypersexualized or suppressed. We fear being misunderstood, so we withhold tenderness. We conflate desire with lust, and affection with temptation. The result is that we have almost no category for holy closeness — nearness that blesses instead of blurring boundaries.

Jonathan and David show us there is a space — rare, but real — for embodied affection that is not erotic. This is not license for unwise intimacy or emotional entanglement. It’s an invitation to imagine a purer form of nearness — one that neither denies the body nor weaponizes it for desire.

Physical closeness can be beautiful, but only when it is submitted to the posture of the heart. The body’s gestures must always be governed by reverence — by a heart that asks not “what can I take from you?” but “how can I honor Christ in how I hold you?”

There is no free pass for affection unmoored from holiness.

But there is sacred permission to recover affection that reflects holiness — affection that speaks the language of loyalty, safety, and covenant.

5. Love That Bears the Weight of Glory

Perhaps that is the invitation of Jonathan and David: to reclaim the sacred middle space where love is both embodied and restrained, tender and reverent. A love that remembers we are dust and spirit — longing for nearness, yet accountable to glory.

Their friendship reminds us that physical closeness need not be feared, but formed.

It must be measured not by intensity but by intention.

Not by what the body wants, but by what the heart worships.

When the body becomes a vessel for covenant love, it no longer threatens holiness; it reveals it.

Jonathan and David’s story isn’t there to scandalize us. It’s there to restore something lost: the possibility that human love, even when it aches and touches and cries, can still be holy.

It is the love that holds without grasping, that draws near without devouring.

It’s the love of a soul knit to another — a love that, in its truest form, points beyond itself, toward the greater Friend who knits Himself to us in grace.

Brenna Blain - Rae Liturgies substack